Our People

Location: Main Office

Leadership

Neil Hamilton, LUTCF

President / CEO

Email Me

419-526-4700

Brian Hamilton

Vice President of Sales

Email Me

419-526-4700

Christine Myers

Chief Financial Officer

Email Me

419-526-4700

Michael Hamilton

Vice President of Commercial Lines

Email Me

614-475-4786

Chris Bellamy

Chief Operating Officer

Email Me

419-526-4700

Customer Service

Tammy Smallstey

Senior Account Manager – Personal Lines

Email Me

419-526-4700

Ronda Stone

Senior Account Manager - Commercial Lines

Email Me

419-526-4700

Amber Nicoletti

Account Manager

Email Me

419-526-4700

Mary Jo Pittenger

Commercial Account Manager

Email Me

419-526-4700

Keelie Speckert

Account Manager

Email Me

419-526-4700

Chris Starkey

Account Manager

Email Me

419-526-4700

Audrey McCartney

Administrative / Account Manager

Email Me

419-526-4700

Krista Carpenter

Administrative

Email Me

419-526-4700

Sales

Ed Gutchall

Agent

Email Me

419-526-4700

John Kennedy

Agent

Email Me

419-526-4700

Sarah Ludwig

Agent

Email Me

419-526-4700

Neil Shideler

Agent

Email Me

419-526-4700

Fern Walton

Life Specialist

Email Me

419-526-4700

Nikki Williamson

Benefits

Email Me

419-526-4700

Lori Holden Sjostedt

Agent

Email Me

419-526-4700

Ryan Teynor

Sales Support

Email Me

419-526-4700

Kurt Barkdull

Agent

Email Me

419-526-4700

Location: Gahanna Office

Michael Hamilton

Vice President of Commercial Lines

Email Me

614-475-4786

Beth Covarrubias

Account Manager

Email Me

614-475-4786

Misty Spring Heffernan

Commercial Lines Account Manager

Email Me

614-475-4786

David Sipes

Agent

Email Me

614-475-4786

Tabitha Bailey

Account Manager

Email Me

614-475-4786